Before sending fired New York City cable television anchor Dominic Carter to jail for domestic abuse on Thursday, Justice Arnold Etelson gave the boistrous Ramapo resident a magazine article.
The article centered on how Hollywood heartthrob actor Matt Damon has stayed humble despite his worldwide fame. Etelson gift referred to Carter’s courtroom antics of boasting that he was a”high-profile journalist” with influential friends.
Carter dropped some names when first brought to court before Etelson in December, apparently seeking a quick dismissal of an assault charge accusing him of beating up his wife in their Ramapo home. The names included Manhattan DA Robert Morgenthau, state Chief Judge Judith Kaye. He boasted of interviewing state and city politicians.
Etelson also gave Marily Carter a “sticker” for their bathroom mirror that states: “Attitude Makes the Difference.” He told her that Dominic Carter should read the sticker every morning.
Etelson was in a giving mood – giving Dominic Carter 30 days in the county jail for third-degree attempted assault, ordering him to undergo psychiatric counseling, take medication and to stay away from his wife for two years.
Etelson also gave Carter a lecture on treating his wife with dignity – citing a decade of abuse complaints against him by her. He also attempted to bolster Marilyn Carter, though she asked Etelson not to sentence her husband to jail. She wanted him home with her and their two children, a 17-year-old son and 22-year-old daughter.
Marilyn Carter called 911 and signed a police complaint saying her husband beat her in October 2008. On the witness stand, she told Etelson that a day laborer she hired had beat her over an argument about money. She couldn’t remember his name.
She said she told police her husband had beat her because she was angry about an argument involving their son’s medical treatment. At Carter’s trial in October, prosecutor Richard Kennison Moran played a recording of Marilyn Carter’s 911 call and presented photos of her swollen lip, cut ear and bruised arm and leg.
Etelson said her revised story was “nothing short of preposterous.”
He implied that Dominic Carter was behind the day laborer story and said Carter could have been charged with suborning perjury. He said Marilyn Carter could have been charged with perjury, except her account typified “the victimization that she has endured.”
Carter dropped his moved to get a stay of sentence and remains in the county jail. He’s appealing his conviction.